Regular movie goers know the formula for this kind of film: Nice guy, nice girl, crazy friend or interloper, romantic rival, misunderstanding and mayhem. Lately, it’s the stuff of I Love You, Man, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Wedding Crashers, etc. Now, we have Dinner for Schmucks.
First off, please let me get this off my chest, I do not support the title of the film. It bothers me. After watching the movie, I’m even more annoyed, because there is no reason to use the word “schmucks,” which some folks find a very offensive term. So…
What is going to make this comedy sink or soar is the cast. Do we care what happens to these characters? Are we willing to watch, while the hijinks and hilarity rise to uncomfortable and ridiculous extremes? In Dinner for Schmucks, Steve Carrell and Paul Rudd make it work. And, newcomer Stephanie Szostak helps with an adorable sweetness. Rudd is the perfect everyman, as Tim, a guy trying to work his way up the ranks of a financial firm. When he’s invited to a party where every rising star at work needs to bring an idiot they can ridicule, he’s appalled, but the lure of the 7th floor office carrot is too much. He runs into Steve Carrell’s Barry, who spends his time making mice dioramas. Is this a blessing or a curse? Barry seems to infect every aspect of Tim’s life. And, their descent is a mindboggling, painful trip into chaos. At one point, I looked at my son and said, “If this gets any more brutal, I’m going to have to leave!” I stayed, and later was amazed at a scene where everything seemed to go haywire, then more crazy things happened, and then, when you thought nothing else could possibly happen, more went wrong. Who wrote this stuff? Well, it turns out a french guy did, and this is an American version of the film, Le Diner de Cons. I think Rudd and Carrell save this one from feeling too mean spirited. In this genre, I usually really dislike the romantic rival character (usually played by Russell Brand or someone of his ilk), here though, Jemaine Clement nearly steals the show as the over the top artist, Kieran, who I found to be hilarious! I give Dinner for Schmucks a 7 out of 10. It should be noted that the two 18 year old dudes with me gave it 8!